Fix your P&L repairs and maintenance line

Over the last several years, Tuckernuck Plaza FSR has made some dramatic improvements that have enabled them to reduce their IPO by nearly 67%. They have seen improvements to their food cost and labor cost, but this update will focus on something less commonly discussed: repair costs.

Peter, Tuckernuck Plaza’s Financial Return Director, recognized that they were spending big money each month to have routine repairs made throughout the Restaurant. He wondered if it would be possible for some of those repairs to be handled in-house. To do that, he knew some education needed to take place.  He elected himself to become the student - and quickly he was able to build up the understanding required so that he could do the routine repairs himself.

Ultimately his education was accomplished in several different ways:
1) When it was necessary to pay for a repair, Peter would stay right next to the repairmen and ask questions about what was being done and why. This helped him determine whether he would be able to make the repair the next time.
2) Peter leveraged his relationships with people who knew a lot about repairs and maintenance. When he had questions about how to fix something, he would call one of those contacts he had made in the repairs business.  His questions were usually met with a great amount of information and provided knowledge he was able to put to use.
3) Peter used social media (for example: YouTube) to educate himself.  He realized there were some good videos out there regarding routine repairs.



It goes without saying, but is a good reminder, that safety must always be the top priority.  However, there are plenty of low-risk, minimal repairs that someone in your Restaurant could possibly handle with the proper education. And your in-house repairman does not have to be your Financial Return Director(s) – it simply requires someone with a mechanical aptitude and willing hands.  Consider having someone within your Restaurant look for opportunities to handle routine repairs in-house.



What items in your Restaurant do you have repaired “in-house”?

“If they aren’t aware, how can they help?”

James Island FSR is working on a 4th consecutive year of keeping their total IPO below 0.75%; and for the second consecutive year, at or below 0.10% total IPO.  They are also approaching the top of their Region for CEM scores and they are getting better each month. This raises the question, "How have they been able to maintain that kind of balance for that length of time?" Following a recent visit with Operator Jason Williams, and his GM/FRD Christine, the one word answer appears to be – communication.  Because maintaining good control on costs and having a strong customer experience is important at James Island FSR, they know that they not only have to make the team aware through good communication, they also have to keep the line of communication consistently effective.

Here are several examples of the communication methods used: 
Team Members
-Each month, see the Restaurant’s food cost performance
-On a routine basis, discuss ways they can directly impact food costs
-Daily, are held accountable for their specific contributions toward good cost controls

Leaders
-Meet regularly as a team
-(Kitchen Leaders) Spend deliberate amounts of time in the kitchen to stay current
-Make use of a “in progress” Word document throughout each day where they carry on relevant conversations, shift specific information, and request purchases that need to be made.  At the end of each day the document is completed and sent out to the entire leadership team.


What is the level of communication in your Restaurant? How could you leverage better communication methods and skills to drive more consistent results?


Improve Labor Productivity By Adding Hours

How can ADDING a few labor hours provide a REDUCTION in labor costs?   What would happen if you invested additional hours in creating and managing the labor schedule each month? Would it be worth your time investment? Could you discover similar savings?  Most of the time, the answer will be a resounding, “Yes!”  With an average FSR’s volume of hours worked being over 5,000 per month and the average mall store having close to 3,000 hours worked per month, on the surface you might think finding hours to cut from the schedule should be easy.  However, maintaining the critical balance between service and productivity can be a challenge. 
The following is the story of how well this investment worked for Mayfair FSR Operator, Billy Lynch.
At Mayfair FSR, Operator Billy Lynch has his Operations Director, Debbie, produce the work schedule. His FRD, Megan, spends time giving Debbie schedule recommendations using last year sales and this year’s trend to forecast sales by the half hour. Plugging this information into a spreadsheet, in which she also inputs the number of people on the clock for each half hour, allows her to see scheduled productivity for each half hour, as well as, for the whole day. Debbie and Megan often engage in a healthy debate about the number of hours that are needed throughout the day.  This discussion produces a push-and-pull approach to creating the schedule and helps Mayfair FSR maintain a good balance between service (top 20% Operational Excellence) and productivity (top 10% productivity in June).   
As you look for opportunities to improve labor productivity, a wise investment could be a few additional hours in understanding your Restaurant’s productivity and how to best schedule to meet those needs. Involving leaders with different perspectives will help you maintain the proper balance between customer experience and productivity. Remember that this information might not require cutting overall scheduling hours for your staff.  It could simply mean a strategic decrease of hours during a less active time and additional hours during peak sales times.  All of which will lead to an increased overall productivity level.
Do you have opportunities to make small investments of time in the schedule?  We would love to hear how your investment pays off for your store.  

A “Specialized” Approach to Getting Results

After Rick Johnson of Greenwood FSR empowered one of his managers, Mark, to own responsibility for Financial Return, the store saw a 64% profit increase from 2010 to 2011. With such a great success behind them, the question now became what to expect for 2012? Rick and Mark both knew they had taken care of the low hanging fruit, so making continued incremental improvement would require more focus and effort in specific areas. One area they determined to address was breakfast, hence the creation of the breakfast specialist. Breakfast was chosen because they had seen breakfast gaps hovering around the $500 range in 2011.
Brooke was a great fit for breakfast specialist because she is energetic, driven, and well respected by the crew. As a breakfast specialist, Brooke was able to keep the team focused on cooking less while cooking more often.  This ensured fresh product, and at the same time, minimized waste. They used the Breakfast Waste Tracker to track the dollar value of waste each day. Early on, there were days when waste hovered as high as $10.00 per day.  However, after several months of intense focus and good communication, breakfast waste was averaging closer to only $2.00 per day.  The impact this has made on their overall waste has proven to keep their total breakfast gap below $200 every month since April!
To recap, Rick felt that focusing most of his attention on Financial Return would not be the best use of his time as an Operator.  At the same time, he also recognized the value of having someone else give it their time, attention and focus. Mark recognized that while he could work to identify trends and help the team stay focused on Financial Return, he would get better results if he had others focusing on day-to-day specific pieces of Financial Return.  Now they are experiencing a 22% YTD Profit Increase (on top of last year’s increase) evidencing that this approach is working well for them!
What areas of Financial Return in your Restaurant could benefit from the use of a specialist?  

Food Cost App Survey

Back in March, readers of this blog were invited to participate in a pilot test for the new Food Cost App. The pilot actually began in late April, and our hope is that many of you have had an opportunity to try out the app. If you have used the app in any capacity, (whether it be daily, or you tried it once and didn't look at it again) we would really appreciate your feedback. We are making plans to roll the app out to the chain in July, so your feedback is very important to us.
Please click on this link to access the survey - http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/7M7KQZK
Just a reminder about what the Food Cost App is all about:
When it comes to cutting down on the D.R.I.P, the new Food Cost App is proving to be a timely and invaluable resource. Operators, Financial Return Directors (FRD) and Team Members from Phase 1 of the test are tapping into this powerful and continually-improving web-based resource for everything from checking in deliveries and tracking transfers, to waste and portion tracking.
For more information please check the March 1st blog post. Or you can view one of the recorded videos below (the videos have been protected by the following password - fcapp).

If you have any questions or would like access to the app please contact Lauren Hayes


FC App – Overview
FC App – Deliveries
FC App – Registers
FC App – Inventory
FC App – Waste Tracking
FC App – Portion Tracking
FC App – Advanced


Conditional Integrity


Disclaimer: this blog is not in any way endorsing or challenging the decision that some Operators have made to install camera systems into Restaurants. Rather, it looks at why camera systems can lower food cost and identifies a few principles we all can learn and apply from Restaurants with camera systems.

In the last blog entry, we asked readers to share things that helped reduce costs in their Restaurants. The response from one individual was interesting, and one that other Operators have shared before: they saw immediate improvement in their food cost when they invested in a camera system.

Why would this be? How can a camera system improve food cost? To answer these questions we must first look at what changes when an Operator installs a camera system. When Operators install this type of system they have greater visibility into what cashiers are doing on the Registers and they often proactively inform their cashiers about the increased visibility. The intent here, they say, is to let cashiers know they’re watching.

Now whether or not installing additional cameras is the right way to let cashiers know that they are accountable for their actions is up to each Operator. The principle here is to keep honest people honest. This is important because, unfortunately, many people lack the integrity to do the right thing no matter what. The same cashier that behaves honestly in some situations will behave dishonestly in other situations. In other words, for many cashiers, circumstances will be the difference in being honest or dishonest. As a result, you’re much better off taking proactive steps to prevent theft than you are trying to detect theft after it has already occurred.

The goal is NOT to create an environment of distrust where cashiers feel like someone is constantly watching their every move. Rather, the idea is to put cashiers in a position where the right decision is very easy to choose, and the wrong decision is undesirable. To do this we recommend five critical behaviors and three examples of ways to remind cashiers that they’re accountable for their actions.

Key behaviors to Keep Honest People honest
  1. Consistently enforce Cash and Coupon Accountability Policy- this is the foundation
  2. One Cashier Per Register- otherwise, you can’t enforce your policy
  3. No one counts their own drawer (even managers!)
  4. Use Swipe cards (rather than pin numbers)
  5. Treat Coupons like cash- count them and hold team members
     Other ways to let people know you’re watching:
  1.       Post the Cashier keystroke report- You could choose to post great or poor performers
  2.       Verify All Refunds- This doesn’t take long and addresses a major area of cash management
  3.      Surprise Drawer Counts - Some Operators (or FRD's) number their registers 1-6 and appear unexpectedly to count a till before the cashier expecst tills to be counted. They roll a dice (to randomize the process) and whatever number the dice lands on is the drawer that gets pulled early. The thought here is that if someone is stealing they'll probably have a cash overage that they were going to take out of the drawer before it was counted. Even if you don't count the drawer of a suspicious cashier, it serves as a deterrent for cashiers to steal, which is the goal.


Look at the lists above for opportunities to improve cash management in your Restaurant. And as always, feel free to share thoughts or experiences in the comments section below.


Educational Opportunities


This post highlights some different financial return educational opportunities available to Operators and Financial Return Directors.

Realizing there is a lot of important information on the internet, especially on @CFA, we would like to showcase some of the great learning opportunities of the Financial Return Directors page on @CFA and show you our link on the Learning Portal.

On the Business Analysis website on @CFA there is a Financial Return Director page.



Take a look at the Getting Started Checklists. They are a great resource to get you and your FRD on the same page regarding financial return.


Also on this page, there are several learning modules. These modules offer best practices for managing food costs, labor costs, and general costs.


If you need help implementing the role, take a look at the Implementation/Execution section on the FRD page. The Job Batches spreadsheet will describe focus areas of great impact for financial return.



The newest educational platform for financial return is on the Learning Portal.


Currently we are only piloting a system for Food. But with its success we are now in the beginning stages of creating a labor module. This system has the same functionality as eTMDP. So, not only is this a format that you are already familiar with but it is organized based on the DRIP model and is designed to help you quickly identify ways to improve your food cost. 


We hope you take advantage of these tools and learning opportunities.