Showing posts with label Best Practices. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Best Practices. Show all posts

Fix your P&L repairs and maintenance line

Over the last several years, Tuckernuck Plaza FSR has made some dramatic improvements that have enabled them to reduce their IPO by nearly 67%. They have seen improvements to their food cost and labor cost, but this update will focus on something less commonly discussed: repair costs.

Peter, Tuckernuck Plaza’s Financial Return Director, recognized that they were spending big money each month to have routine repairs made throughout the Restaurant. He wondered if it would be possible for some of those repairs to be handled in-house. To do that, he knew some education needed to take place.  He elected himself to become the student - and quickly he was able to build up the understanding required so that he could do the routine repairs himself.

Ultimately his education was accomplished in several different ways:
1) When it was necessary to pay for a repair, Peter would stay right next to the repairmen and ask questions about what was being done and why. This helped him determine whether he would be able to make the repair the next time.
2) Peter leveraged his relationships with people who knew a lot about repairs and maintenance. When he had questions about how to fix something, he would call one of those contacts he had made in the repairs business.  His questions were usually met with a great amount of information and provided knowledge he was able to put to use.
3) Peter used social media (for example: YouTube) to educate himself.  He realized there were some good videos out there regarding routine repairs.



It goes without saying, but is a good reminder, that safety must always be the top priority.  However, there are plenty of low-risk, minimal repairs that someone in your Restaurant could possibly handle with the proper education. And your in-house repairman does not have to be your Financial Return Director(s) – it simply requires someone with a mechanical aptitude and willing hands.  Consider having someone within your Restaurant look for opportunities to handle routine repairs in-house.



What items in your Restaurant do you have repaired “in-house”?

A “Specialized” Approach to Getting Results

After Rick Johnson of Greenwood FSR empowered one of his managers, Mark, to own responsibility for Financial Return, the store saw a 64% profit increase from 2010 to 2011. With such a great success behind them, the question now became what to expect for 2012? Rick and Mark both knew they had taken care of the low hanging fruit, so making continued incremental improvement would require more focus and effort in specific areas. One area they determined to address was breakfast, hence the creation of the breakfast specialist. Breakfast was chosen because they had seen breakfast gaps hovering around the $500 range in 2011.
Brooke was a great fit for breakfast specialist because she is energetic, driven, and well respected by the crew. As a breakfast specialist, Brooke was able to keep the team focused on cooking less while cooking more often.  This ensured fresh product, and at the same time, minimized waste. They used the Breakfast Waste Tracker to track the dollar value of waste each day. Early on, there were days when waste hovered as high as $10.00 per day.  However, after several months of intense focus and good communication, breakfast waste was averaging closer to only $2.00 per day.  The impact this has made on their overall waste has proven to keep their total breakfast gap below $200 every month since April!
To recap, Rick felt that focusing most of his attention on Financial Return would not be the best use of his time as an Operator.  At the same time, he also recognized the value of having someone else give it their time, attention and focus. Mark recognized that while he could work to identify trends and help the team stay focused on Financial Return, he would get better results if he had others focusing on day-to-day specific pieces of Financial Return.  Now they are experiencing a 22% YTD Profit Increase (on top of last year’s increase) evidencing that this approach is working well for them!
What areas of Financial Return in your Restaurant could benefit from the use of a specialist?  

Food Cost App Survey

Back in March, readers of this blog were invited to participate in a pilot test for the new Food Cost App. The pilot actually began in late April, and our hope is that many of you have had an opportunity to try out the app. If you have used the app in any capacity, (whether it be daily, or you tried it once and didn't look at it again) we would really appreciate your feedback. We are making plans to roll the app out to the chain in July, so your feedback is very important to us.
Please click on this link to access the survey - http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/7M7KQZK
Just a reminder about what the Food Cost App is all about:
When it comes to cutting down on the D.R.I.P, the new Food Cost App is proving to be a timely and invaluable resource. Operators, Financial Return Directors (FRD) and Team Members from Phase 1 of the test are tapping into this powerful and continually-improving web-based resource for everything from checking in deliveries and tracking transfers, to waste and portion tracking.
For more information please check the March 1st blog post. Or you can view one of the recorded videos below (the videos have been protected by the following password - fcapp).

If you have any questions or would like access to the app please contact Lauren Hayes


FC App – Overview
FC App – Deliveries
FC App – Registers
FC App – Inventory
FC App – Waste Tracking
FC App – Portion Tracking
FC App – Advanced


How Did You Do It?

Spring is traditionally the appropriate moment for sprucing up, cleaning out and turning over a new leaf. Whether your Restaurant’s goal is to cut food cost, reach a new Productivity Benchmark, or put your overall financials in order, this spring could be your opportunity to start down that road to improvement. But real change doesn't come easy.  While the first of the month is customarily a great time to start trying to turn things around, often, the end of that same month will be a just another time for giving up and going back to the old status quo.  

With that in mind, we're asking you - our Financial Return Director blog readers -- to tell us your best financial return success stories. Whether your struggle involved getting Team Member buy-in, maintaining FRD focus, or changing financial return responsibilities to a new leader, we're betting that you have a money tale to tell, a tip that helped you in your efforts to turn towards your goals, or a secret strategy for setting your Financial Return Director up for success. 


So if you've got a suggestion you are willing to pass on or a method for making a financial return improvement last beyond Memorial Day, please let us in on the secret! Either tell us your story in the comments section below, or send your suggestion to lauren.hayes@chick-fil-a.com. We'll publish some of the best stories in the upcoming weeks.

New Report Galleries system on @Chick-fil-A

An exciting opportunity exists for Financial Return Directors to gain direct access to vital reports on @CFA!   Having this report data at their fingertips could be a potential game changer for those in the role of Financial Return Director.

IT released a new, fully rebuilt Report Galleries system on @CFA after receiving input from the MY IT Ideas site (from the IT home page).  This new system enables those using the Role Permissions page to grant access to crucial reports. We encourage Financial Return Directors to speak with their Operator so they can be granted log-in access and begin to take advantage of this great opportunity!

Operators can update FRD access by going to @Chick-fil-A > People > Team Member User Admin and then select Modify Restaurant Role Permissions from the left toolbar. For further information or details on this process, look at the official document provided by IT here. 

A sample of available reporting breakouts is listed below and you can see the most current reporting breakouts by going here.


For further information or help, please contact Lauren Hayes.  

Food Cost App

When it comes to cutting down on the D.R.I.P, the new Food Cost App is proving to be a timely and invaluable resource. Operators, Financial Return Directors (FRD) and Team Members from Phase 1 of the test are tapping into this powerful and continually-improving web-based resource for everything from checking in deliveries and tracking transfers, to waste and portion tracking. The app will be available to all Restaurants with registered FRD(s) beginning March 19th so please contact Lauren Hayes if your Restaurant would like to be part of the test.

App Capabilities
The Food Cost app will be web-based, which means it will be available for multiple devices including PC’s, tablets, and smart phones. Some of the key features include the following:
  • A summary of Food Cost opportunities in your Restaurant.
    The app will highlight areas of opportunity based on the criteria that your Restaurant creates.
  • Track Delivery Issues by Vendor
    Keep up with outstanding vendor credits
    Keep up with food transfers to and from other Chick-fil-A's
  • Paperless Cashier Accountability
    Ability to edit Cashier issue status as resolved or not resolved

    Sortable Cashier History list by Cashier Name, Issue, Status, and Date
  • KIV Variance Tracker
    Adjustable threshold to personalize this tool for your Restaurant

    Comment box to insert specific details about what may have happened on a specific day.
  • Paperless Waste Tracker
    Breakfast AND Lunch/Dinner tracking forms

    Adjustable tolerances to personalize this tool for your Restaurant
  • Paperless Portion Tracker
    Range drop down box for simple input

    History Reporting

    App Training Opportunities 
    You will have multiple ways to learn how to use the Food Cost app. These include text documentation, a self-led e-learning module, & live Webinars. Information about each of these training options will be sent to the Restaurants that sign up for the test.


    App Best Practices
    Consistent use of the Food Cost App will enable you to identify and address specific needs in your Restaurant. After identifying areas of opportunity, use the app to track your Restaurants progress based on your particular needs and goals.

    Following the test run of the App, we will send out a simple survey for your feedback. This information will help us improve the app before we will roll it out to the chain.

    We hope you will be part of the Food Cost App Test! Please let us know if you have any questions.

    Results AND Relationships

    Did you know that having responsibility over Financial Return provides you with both very tangible data you can use to reduce your food cost gap and the information you need to strengthen team relationships?  If the actions you have taken are creating the measureable results you seek, you are able to see that data by the end of the month, or sooner if you have good systems in place.  While these findings are vital to reduce your food cost gap, that is not the only benefit of Financial Return.  You can also use the same data as a tool to evaluate performance and help you maintain healthy relationships.
    There’s no question that your job as an FRD is to get results. In the short run, it is possible to achieve great results looking only at data. However, to maintain your achievements you will need the support, cooperation, and buy-in of the team.  This is clearly seen from the Operators feedback since implementing the Financial Return Director concept.  Sustainable results cannot come at the cost of relationships.  So use your data to also help you acknowledge  the ones who helped you achieve the results – especially realizing that they may have gone unappreciated and undervalued previously. 
    Think about it – a little acknowledgement goes a long way!  When people feel like they have not only contributed but have also been noticed for it, they will most likely continue to seek that acknowledgement.  Obtain your desired results – but then maintain them with solid relationships!
    Here are a few personal reflection questions to help you consider how well you are balancing results and relationships:
    1. Am I treating others the way I would like to be treated?
    2. Am I taking the time to understand another’s point of view?
    3. Do I ask others for suggestions on how to improve results or do I just dole out “orders”?
    4. How often do I tell others “Thank you” for what they do?

    Improve your productivity 15 minutes at a time

    The best way to optimize labor cost in your Restaurant is by maximizing productivity over time. This post will cover one of the most effective ways to maximize your productivity: utilizing 15-minute increment scheduling.

    What is 15-minute increment scheduling?

    The purpose of 15-minute increment scheduling is to match Team Members’ hours with sales. Use of this schedule allows you to maximize productivity by waiting to bring Team Members when they are most needed and then send them home as sales begin to drop.

    Why should my Restaurant use 15-minute increment scheduling?

    1. Smoother Transitions
      When several Team Members clock-in at the same time, there is a tendency to talk more and take longer to assume their respective areas of responsibility in the Restaurant which could ultimately hurt the customer’s experience. Limiting the number of Team Members who funnel in or out at the same time will help avoid this situation.

    2. Higher Productivity, Lower Labor Cost, and Higher Profits!
      By using the 15-minute increment scheduling you can reduce a Team Member's hours without dramatically impacting their income, while at the same time, greatly impacting your labor cost. For example, you can trim an average of 15 minutes per shift for 16 shifts per day and reduce your labor cost by 4 hours per day.
      Note: if you are looking to reduce your hours using 15 minute increments, start with your least productive employees and work your way up.

    What now?
    Look at your most recent schedule and count the number of shifts that begin or end in a 15-minute increment. Try to increase the count of these shifts by at least 5 each week until you feel like you are maximizing 15-minute increment scheduling in your Restaurant.

    Use the Labor Report (from Service Point) to determine the hours of the day are least productive and look for ways to leverage 15-minute increments to improve those hours. 

    Chocolate AND Peanut Butter

    On December 7th, the field Marketing Consultants and Financial Consultants held the first CFA Reese's Summit.  You may ask, "Why the candy reference?"  This is because Sales and Profits go together like Chocolate and Peanut Butter. While each is great on its own, they're even better when you put them together. Just like a perfect Reese’s.

    At the summit, the two groups spent the day learning more about each other’s work and looking for future opportunities to partner together.  The summit was a unique opportunity for the groups to work together because of the common stereotype that marketing and finance types have conflicting goals for the business. A good example of this misconception is that marketing people want you to spend, spend, spend to grow sales; while finance people want you to cut, cut, cut to reduce costs. Truthfully, when the Financial and Marketing Consultants both shared their goals for the business, there was an encouraging response: Both groups' ultimately want to help grow Operator Income over time.

    As a result of the Reese’s Summit, throughout 2012 both groups will intentionally look for ways to help Restaurants tap into "the power of AND" by growing sales and maximizing profits.  So, the hope is that FRD's similarly approach 2012 by looking for ways to help grow sales AND profits.  Here are three recommendations you can present to your team:

    1)Grow check average!   Check average growth is one of the best ways to increase profits because it is inexpensive and over 50% of the increase can fall straight to the bottom line! Click here to see a previous blog post with check average best practices.

    2)Help the team see labor in light of productivity (sales/ hours), not labor percentage. Productivity is about generating maximum sales relative to hours worked. This could mean adding people during peak times (and removing people during non-peaks). The key here is to be sure you're scheduling to grow.

    3)Be a champion for sampling. It's a proven way to grow check average and introduce customers to new and unfamiliar products. It's also very inexpensive relative to the potential check average growth. 

    Get what you pay for this December

    The November BANK Newsletter mentions how the holiday season brings with it financial challenges that make people more likely to steal. While the BANK focused on how this issue impacts cash management, the same principle applies to deliveries.

    Numerous Operators can tell stories about being cheated by bread or produce vendors at some point in their career. The plot usually goes something like this: "Our bread guy was very friendly and always quick to greet everyone he saw. He would take care of rotating the bread himself, and would even drop off sweets for us from time to time. We were very pleased with his level of service. As it turns out, he was billing us for more bread than we were receiving and pocketing the difference. We never suspected anything like that was happening."

    While it's disappointing to hear stories like this one, the good news is that this is very easy to prevent: Check in all orders to verify the quality and quantity. If the product quality or quantity does not match the invoice then have the vendor adjust it to reflect what you actually received. 

    Hopefully, every Restaurant in the chain has had this conversation with the Team Leaders who check in their deliveries. However, as you know, what people are asked to do and what they actually do tend to  differ--especially when they're busy.



    Here's 3 tips for overseeing the deliveries process and ensuring that your Restaurant gets what it pays for:
    1)Conduct a weekly audit of the check in process
    Drop in unannounced to check the individual who signed in the delivery to make sure that you actually received the amount on the receipt. Be sure to inspect the quality and quantity of the product.
    2)Ask your bread or produce vendor to intentionally short you
    Simply ask them to bring less food into the Restaurant than the invoice shows. If the Team Leader who checks the delivery in does not catch the shortage, then you know you have some work to do with that individual. This also lets the delivery person know that you're working with your team on proper check in.
    3)Maintain a credit log to keep track of all outstanding credits
    Follow this log closely to ensure that you actually receive the credits that your vendors agree to give you.

    We would love to hear any stories or experiences you have had with vendor-related issues in the comments section.

    A Couple Nuggets to Consider

    When looking at the Target Food Cost Report many Restaurants find Nuggets highlighted as one of their top three areas of opportunity. This can occur for a number of reasons ranging from excessive waste, to Team Member consumption, to supplier-related issues. But let's highlight an aspect of managing nuggets that often gets overlooked: portioning.

    On the surface, it seems like nugget portioning would be a no brainer. You put 8 nuggets in the 8-count box and 12 nuggets in the 12-count box. But as you know, it's not always that easy. Chick-fil-A nuggets vary in size because they're not stamped into a certain shape like McDonald's nuggets. As a result, there is a range of acceptable nugget sizes that you can serve to guests. Some nuggets are on the high end of the range and some are on the low end.

    For example, if a customer gets 8 nuggets on the low end of the acceptable range, they will likely feel like they've been cheated. To compensate, many Chick-fil-A's will add an extra nugget to make the box look full. On the flip-side if they get 8 nuggets on the high end of the range, they'll just assume that's what an 8-count is supposed to look like every time. We definitely don't want to cheat our guests, but we don't want to cheat ourselves either. As a result, consider the following tips to help Team Members consistently portion nuggets correctly. 

    1) Mix the nuggets after placing them in the holding pan: When your nuggets are cooking the smaller nuggets tend to float to the top and the larger nuggets sink toward the bottom. As a result, when you dump the cooked nuggets into the holding pan, the larger nuggets will be on top and the smaller nuggets will be on the bottom. If you do not mix the nuggets you will use up all your larger nuggets first and you'll end up needing to put extra nuggets in the box once your get down to just the smaller nuggets. By simply mixing, you can place multiple sizes in a box, which will enable you to get both an acceptable count and weight. This will take some practice.

    2) Educate Team Members- The Financial Return Director and/or Training Director should spend time explaining proper nugget portioning to Team Members to help them better understand what to do. Otherwise, once a Team Member is told to put extra nuggets in the box a few times, they may default to always putting extra nuggets in the box, just to be safe.

    3) Spot check- Make it a habit in your Restaurant to have someone weigh nugget boxes a couple times throughout the day. Page 37 of the Quality Requirements Guide provides a range of what packaged nuggets should weigh. Use these spot checks to identify coaching opportunities.

    As always, we encourage you to share your thoughts and ideas in the comments section below.

    Paper or Plastic?


    We're keeping it short and sweet this week. Check out two best practices below to identify ways to improve paper cost with minimal time or effort.

    1) Implement the "plastic cup trick"
    You've all seen it dozens of times. The last cup or two usually gets destroyed when removing it from the cup holder. To avoid this, place a plastic cup in the holder first, and then insert the rest of the cups onto the plastic cup. This will prevent the cup holder from claiming any more cups, and rescue a cup or two per sleeve.

    2) Monitor employee usage of cups
    There are a number of ways to do this. You may choose to provide Team Members with plastic washable cups, use inexpensive cone-shaped cups for team members to use throughout a shift, or limit Team Members to one Chick-fil-A cup per shift. However you approach it, be sure your Team Members are not wasting Chick-fil-A cups throughout their shifts.

    Go forth and increase profits!

    10:30

    The average Chick-fil-A Restaurant has a $500 breakfast gap each month. That's roughly $20 per day. While over portioning during the breakfast day part is a possible contributor, we challenge you to consider looking at the breakfast transition for the next couple weeks.

    At 10:30 each day, have someone take a moment to track how much breakfast the Restaurant is about to waste. This will give you a better understanding of how much of the food you waste during this transition is contributing to your breakfast gap. Consider inputting this information into the Breakfast Waste Calculator on the Business Analysis website.

    Based on what you observe at 10:30, consider the following ACTION STEPS to reduce waste at transition time:

    1.      Use the Sales Mix Report (Time Interval Report for 15 minute increments) to determine how much of each product you sell (or don't sell) throughout the morning.
    2.      Using the information from the Sales Mix Report and your waste observations, consider creating a drop guide to specify the quantity of breakfast items to cook at different times during the breakfast day part (keep in mind that this will  look different on Monday than it does on Saturday).
    3.      The 5 most expensive breakfast items to waste are as follows:
    Sausage, Bacon, Eggs, Mini Rolls, and Oatmeal.

    Some Restaurants have stopped focusing on the breakfast subcategory because they've consistently had a gap. While achieving a breakfast gap of zero may be a very aggressive goal, if you can reduce your breakfast gap that occurs at 10:30 AM, you should at least expect to see the gap move in the right direction.

    Please share your thoughts or ideas below.


    Big Food Cost Improvement Opportunity: COATER

    When looking at food cost gaps by subcategory, it's always helpful to identify subcategories that present the most opportunity for improvement. A subcategory that consistently shows in the top 3 for highest gap is coater. The average coater gap for the chain is .14% YTD. However, a number of Restaurants have been able to take their coater gaps to zero. Here some simple best practices to help you do the same.


    1.   Move it! Many Chick-fil-A Restaurants store a large number of coater bags above the breading table for convenience. However, some Restaurants have found that if the coater is harder to get to people will be more careful with it and therefore less wasteful. So, consider moving your coater somewhere else in the Restaurant and only having enough coater for one day of business above the breading table.


    2.     Don't over-fill the pan- To ensure that quality standards are met, your breader must have enough coater in the pan to adequately bread the chicken. However, if you put too much coater in the pan, you'll have to throw away that extra coater at the end of the day. Consider going to a smaller pan for coater at the end of the day when you're slower so you can maintain the proper depth of coater while using less coater to do so.


    3.    Use KIV- Using KIV to track coater will enable you to measure how well your team is managing coater usage on a daily basis. This will provide you with immediate feedback on how your team is doing with implementing different recommended changes that are shared by you or other leaders. If you do not know how to use KIV, click on this link to learn more.


    4.   For additional tips about managing coater and other subcategories check out the Lowering Food Cost by Subcategory document on the Business Analysis Tools Page
                                                                                                                                                                                   
    If you've had success with reducing your coater gap please share your success in the COMMENTS section below.

    The Power of Partnering With Other PCs

    To increase your Restaurant's effectiveness of managing financial return, consider having your Profit Champion(s) meet with PC's from other Restaurants. Odds are the Chick-fil-A up the road is encountering similar challenges and they're possibly even pursuing similar goals. However, there's a good chance that their Restaurant is not approaching these challenges and goals in exactly the same ways as your team. By connecting your PC with another PC they can learn from each other and the different approaches that each Restaurant takes when approaching different problems.

    Operator, Rich Ubele, has seen great value in this approach. His Profit Champion, Laurel, meets with two other PC's bi-weekly to discuss opportunities and to encourage and challenge each other. Here's what Laurel had to say about their approach:

    "We always bring our most current IPO's, food cost report, labor cost reports, and keystroke reports.  We exchange each other's keystroke reports and look for and address problems.  We have a open honesty policy.  Sharing the hard situations and difficult questions so we can grow and move forward. We have an agenda that we try to follow each week but are also sensitive to the evolution of the day to day"

    Laurel goes on to endorse this approach by saying "I would 100% recommend that other PC's meet together.  The value of getting to work with other people who are sharing the same responsibilities as your own is priceless. You do not always have to re-create the wheel, sometimes you just have to be reminded which spoke you are missing.  I cherish the time I get to spend with Robin, and Sheila."

    By the way, Laurel and Rich's positive feedback about this approach is validated by their results: a 30% IPO decrease in the first half of 2011! And all signs point towards continued improvement in the months to come.

    Rich says, "The value that I see with Laurel spending time with other PC's is priceless!" I hope you'll give this approach a try and find the same to be true for you.